“Michigan does not make fertility or the desire to have children a prerequisite for obtaining a marriage license.” http://t.co/wupembjXd8
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
“The Court finds Regnerus’s testimony entirely unbelievable and not worthy of serious consideration.” #DeBoer #ssm http://t.co/shaDdgPsvp
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
really hope the #DeBoer ruling ends Regnerus’ days as an “expert” witness on families headed by same-sex partnerships. #ssm #shoddyscience
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
also love how Judge Friedman puts “study” in scare quotes when talking about the Regernus testimony. #DeBoer #ssm
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
“Defendants argued that…heterosexual married couples provide the optimal environment for…children. The Court rejects this rationale.”
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
Friedman makes point we don’t legally exclude “sub-optimal” straight couples from parenting based on group status. http://t.co/PB2lQ7Pjd8
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
“While the justices recognized the state’s expansive power in the realm of domestic relations, they also noted…this power has its limits.”
— feministlibrarian (@feministlib) March 22, 2014
Judge Friedman also turned up the snark to full volume by pointing out, in a quote too long to excerpt on Twitter, that:
Taking the state defendants’ position to its logical conclusion, the empirical evidence at hand should require that only rich, educated, suburban-dwelling, married Asians may marry, to the exclusion of all other heterosexual couples. Obviously the state has not adopted this policy and with good reason. The absurdity of such a requirement is self-evident. Optimal academic outcomes for children cannot logically dictate which groups may marry.
As of this writing, Michigan marriage licenses for same-sex couples are on hold until further review, but it’s worth noting that Friedman himself didn’t issue the stay — I think it’s pretty clear he’s had enough of these anti-gay shenanigans.
And finally, for anyone who missed it on Twitter and Facebook, my father wrote a lovely obituary for my grandmother (his mom) which appeared in the local paper this past Wednesday.